The Witnesses To My Accident All Tell Different Stories. How Will The Jury Know What To Believe?

by Friedman & Ranzenhofer, PC on February 16, 2011

in Buffalo Injury Questions and Answers

Experienced Buffalo personal injury attorneys will tell you that in some cases, having a lot of witnesses to an accident can make it more difficult to determine what actually happened – not easier.  It is not at all unusual for two witnesses – both of whom are truthfully speaking to the best of their recall – to provide completely different versions of an event.

Most personal injury accidents happen quickly, and the witnesses are likely to be more focused on avoiding injury to themselves or helping the parties involved than on remembering every little detail.  This fact, and the passage of time between the accident and the need for witness testimony, often leads to great differences in how people recall an accident.

It is up to the jury to weigh the evidence presented to them and determine what they actually believe.  It is up to your personal injury attorney to obtain information from witnesses in a way that will be helpful to your case.  A skillful personal injury attorney should be able to elicit the evidence necessary for the jury’s consideration to help your case when examining the witnesses.

In some cases, it may also be possible to reconstruct exactly how an accident happened based on the physical evidence.   In such a case, your personal injury attorney may wish to hire an expert who can look at the physical evidence and present testimony regarding exactly how the accident occurred.

{ 0 comments… add one now }

Leave a Comment